When it comes to measuring a company’s economic well-being, people have it wrong on two levels, according to panelists at Friday’s Society of Business Editors and Writers conference. In short: neither statisticians nor journalists have found the real story behind gross domestic product.
The director of the United States Department of Commerce Bureau of Economic Analysis joined the growing debate shared by political leaders like President Barack Obama and French President Nicholas Sarkozy over just how adequate gross domestic product has been in measuring a country’s welfare. While there is no way to quantify happiness, said director Steve Landefeld, the BEA’s measures have been lacking. In fact, with better statistical analysis, they might have better predicted the housing bubble and financial crisis.
The “data really fell down on the job,” said Landefeld, as he showed charts that described a huge disparity between personal income and housing prices and data analysis that indicated little difference between Lehman Brothers or Bear Sterns and other, less-leveraged banks. A copy of Landefeld’s “GDP and Beyond” is available here and from the BEA.
The BEA should be comb over data more closely to better show bubbles and guide more sustainable practices, he said.
There may be even more to our misunderstanding of GDP than that, said fellow panelist Mike Mandel, editor in chief of Visible Economy LLC and former chief economist of Bloomberg Businessweek. The notion that consumer spending is 70 percent of GDP-used ad nauseam by journalists around the country – is misleading and just plain wrong, said Mandel.
Personal consumption expenditures does indeed account for roughly 70 percent of GDP. But PCE includes $1 trillion government spending on Medicare, Medicaid and Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP), said Mandel.
It also includes spending on imports. In the second quarter of 2010, consumer spending on motor vehicles rose by more than 6 percent. But domestic motor vehicle output fell by 2.6 percent during that time.
It’s a lot more complicated that many journalists have indicated, said Mandel.
The statement that consumer spending drives the economy is misleading, he reiterated. “It leads you to the wrong story.”




